MP3 vs WAV vs OGG: Which Audio Format Should You Use for BGM?
Which format should you use for downloaded BGM?
When you download free background music or sound effects, you’ll usually see several file formats, such as MP3 and WAV. Many people think, “They all sound the same to me, so I’ll just go with MP3.”
For casual listening, that’s fine. But if you already know how you’ll use the track, such as editing a video, building it into a game, or playing it on a stream, choosing the right format brings real benefits: smaller files, less loss of quality, and no awkward gaps at loop points.
This column covers the differences between the three most common formats and how to choose one for each use.
How compression works: lossy vs. lossless
The key to understanding the formats is how they compress audio.
- Lossy compression: Discards information that is hard for the human ear to hear in order to make the file smaller. The discarded information cannot be recovered (MP3, OGG Vorbis, etc.)
- Lossless compression: Makes the file smaller without discarding any information (FLAC, etc.)
- Uncompressed: Stores the recorded sound exactly as it is (the typical form of WAV)
Strictly speaking, WAV is the name of a file “container,” and it can also hold compressed audio. However, the WAV files commonly used for distribution and editing are almost always uncompressed.
Comparing the three formats
| Format | Compression | File size | Compatibility | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MP3 | Lossy | Small | Plays on almost every device and app | Distribution, sharing, listening on a phone, publishing on the web |
| WAV | Usually uncompressed | Large | Widely supported by editing software | Editing, processing, archiving, source data for the final export |
| OGG (Vorbis) | Lossy | Small | Often supported by game development tools | Building into games, or when you want a format that isn’t tied to patents |
OGG is also, strictly speaking, a container name, and the audio inside it is most often encoded with Vorbis. At the same bitrate (the amount of data per second), it is said to tend to sound better than MP3. However, how it sounds depends on the source material, the encoder (the conversion software) and the listener, so we can’t say it is always better.
File size in numbers
CD-quality audio (44.1 kHz, 16-bit, stereo) recorded as-is produces about 1,411 kbps (kilobits per second) of data. Using that as a baseline, let’s work out roughly how big a 3-minute BGM track would be.
| Format | Bitrate | Size for 3 minutes (approx.) | Share of CD quality |
|---|---|---|---|
| WAV (uncompressed) | about 1,411 kbps | about 32 MB | 100% |
| MP3 | 320 kbps | about 7.2 MB | about 23% |
| MP3 | 128 kbps | about 2.9 MB | about 9% |
For example, suppose you put 30 BGM tracks in a game, each 3 minutes long. As WAV that comes to about 950 MB. As 320 kbps MP3 it’s about 216 MB, and as 128 kbps MP3 it’s about 86 MB. For browser games and mobile games, that difference translates directly into loading wait times and download size.
Note that these bitrate figures are theoretical estimates. Actual files are slightly larger because of metadata, such as song title information.
How different do they actually sound?
Some people think “MP3 sounds bad,” but it depends on the bitrate.
- 128 kbps: Experienced listeners may be able to hear things like muddiness in the high frequencies
- 192 kbps: Many people are said to notice a clear difference from 128 kbps
- 256 to 320 kbps: For ordinary listening, it is often hard to tell the difference from the original
These are rules of thumb (“this is often the case”) and vary with your playback equipment and the genre of music. For BGM heard through a phone speaker or earphones, MP3 at around 320 kbps rarely causes problems. On the other hand, if you plan to process or edit the audio, we recommend using data that is as undegraded as possible.
Recommended formats by use
| Use | Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Importing into video editing software | WAV, or high-bitrate MP3 | Editing software usually supports both. If you’ll export many times, WAV is the safer choice |
| Building into a game (looping music) | OGG or WAV | Check the official guidance for your game development tool. With MP3, silence can be added before and after the track, which can make the loop point noticeable |
| Building into a game (sound effects) | WAV | Short sounds are small anyway, and playback is less likely to be delayed |
| Playing on a live stream | MP3 | Easy to handle and works in almost any playback software |
| Publishing on a web page | MP3 (add OGG too if needed) | Supported by many browsers and the files are small |
| Playing in shops or at events | MP3 (256 kbps or higher) or WAV | If it will play through large speakers, avoid very low bitrates |
Support for loop points differs between game development tools, so also check other articles such as tips for looping BGM cleanly in game development.
Three things to avoid: how to prevent quality loss
1. Exporting an MP3 to MP3 again
If you process a lossy file and save it again in a lossy format, the quality drops a little each time. Avoid repeating the cycle of “edit the MP3, save as MP3.” The basic approach is to keep your working files as WAV while editing, and convert to MP3 or OGG only once, at the very end.
2. Converting an MP3 to WAV and thinking it became “high quality”
Converting an MP3 to WAV does not bring back the information that was already discarded. Only the file size gets bigger. Remember that the quality of the original data is the upper limit.
3. Raising the bitrate afterward
Re-exporting a 128 kbps file at 320 kbps does not improve the sound. The number just gets bigger. Decide the bitrate you need before you save.
A 3-step guide when you’re not sure
- Decide the use: video, game, streaming, web or shop
- Decide whether you’ll edit it: if you’ll process it, use WAV; if you’ll use it as is, MP3 is enough
- Check your size limits: look at the upload limit or your game’s distribution size limit, then decide the bitrate
On Otomusu, you can pick and download tracks from the instrumental BGM list. Before you use them, it’s a good idea to check the Terms of Use for the conditions on commercial use and publication.
Summary
- MP3 and OGG are small lossy formats, while WAV is typically uncompressed and keeps the audio information as it is
- For a 3-minute BGM track, expect roughly 32 MB for WAV, about 7.2 MB for 320 kbps MP3 and about 2.9 MB for 128 kbps MP3
- Use WAV while editing and processing, and convert to MP3 or OGG only for the final export, to keep quality loss to a minimum
- In games, the format is sometimes determined by loop playback requirements, so check your tool’s official guidance
- Repeatedly exporting from lossy to lossy, or raising the bitrate afterward, does not improve sound quality
Once you know the differences between the formats, you can calmly deal with problems like “the file is too heavy,” “the sound is distorted,” or “silence appears at the loop point.” To start, try just one track in the format that suits what you’re making right now.
Terms of use for the assets
- Free
- No registration
- Commercial use OK
- Edits OK
- Credit optional
- No usage report needed
See the terms of use for details.
Related articles
- How to Keep a Record of the BGM and Assets You Use: A Simple Used-Track List So You're Never Stuck Later
- Why I Built Otomusu and Where It's Headed: The Meaning Behind 'Tying Sounds Together'
- Free BGM Commercial Use Checklist: 7 Things to Check Before You Publish
- How Otomusu Free BGM and Pixel Art Are Made: Our Production Workflow (Behind-the-Scenes Notes)
